Friday, May 4, 2012

Kentucky Oaks 138 Analysis and Picks



By Mike Porcaro
Midwest Thoroughbred
www.mwtmag.com

“Contentious,” is what one veteran turf writer told me when I asked him what he thought about the field in the 138th running of the Kentucky Oaks.

I guess a race featuring Grace Hall, On Fire Baby, Broadway’s Alibi and Summer Applause and others of similar talent could be called contentious.

#9 Grace Hall….is the 5-2 favorite after winning the Gulfstream Park Oaks (GII) by 6-1/2 lengths at the 1-1/8 distance and losing by just a neck in the Davona Dale (GII) in her two races as a three-year old. Lifetime, the Empire Maker daughter is 6/4-2-0 with $809,000 in winnings. But today she takes on the challenge of #1 On Fire Baby and #6 Broadway’s Alibi with both posting Beyer speed figures well into the 90’s in each of their last two races. Broadway Alibi hit the 100 mark in winning the Forward gal (GII) two back.

All three of these horses appear to be able to handle the 1-1/8 miles distance and we could see a three horse race. However, #4 Eden’s Moon, 12-1 on the ML, who has won two of her four career races with a second and a third, looks like she can stretch too and should be in the mix.

Of much interest is #3 Summer Applause, the Bret Calhoun charge, who lost by a head in the Fair Grounds Oaks to #9 Believe You Can and won the Rachel Alexandra (GIII) in February. She hit speed figures of 95 and 96 in those races. At 15-1, she is a must include.

The one that intrigues me is #8 Jemima’s Pearl (Distorted Humor), who made her second U.S. start at Oak Lawn in the Fantasy (GII) finishing third just two out. Her first 5 races were run in Ireland. The stretch from 1-1/16 to 1-1/8 will help and her 10-1 odds are appealing. Looks to improve and can win this.

#5 Hard Not to Like is hard not to like after finishing second by just ¾ in the Ashland. What I like most is that she also finished just three back to 2011 BC Turf Filly’s winner Stephanie’s Kitten in that race placing fifth. 

I don’t know what happened to #9 Believe You Can in the Rachel Alexandra where she finished more than 7 from the winner, but she bounced back well in winning the Fair Ground Oaks. Rosie ride for Larry Jones and the jock have already run a big one today with St. John’s River in the LaTroienne.

I can’t dismiss #13 Amie’s Dini for part, but the post hurts as does her running style in a speed laden race. That said St. John’s River came in second in this race last year off the same post. Her problem is that she runs up front and doesn’t close the way St. John’s does and with a ton of speed up front, including her, I doubt she can win.

#11 Karlovy Vary won the Ashland and that’s good. In her lone dirt race, and it was at this track, she lost by more than 12 lengths and that’s bad. The post doesn’t help, but James Graham up does.

Mike’s Picks
#6 Broadway’s Alibi….the work coming into this, the form and 4 straight wins….to win and place. Not crazy about this race being a speed ball for her, but in Johnny V. I trust.
#1 On Fire Baby….2 for 2 at this track; Joe Johnson is the right pilot to take her off the rail and stalk toward the finishing close.
#8 Jemima’s Pearl….more than a hunch; much improvement today and Talamo is moving up the charts.
#2 Grace Hall….got to love her, but I think speed here might hurt.
#3 Summer Applause…..part of the speed package, but should sit back a bit.
#4 Eden’s Moon.  Gets caught in the last furlong to fade?

$20 ex key: 6/1
$10 ex key: 6/2,3,8
$5 ex whl: 1,2,3,8/6
$3 tri whl: 6/1,2,3,8/1,2,3,4,5,8
$1 tri whl: 1,3,6/1,2,3,6/1,2,3,4,5,6,8


No comments:

Post a Comment